[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
Re: GG & Perahia
From: Fred Stubbings <velfred@EARTHLINK.NET>
Reply-To: velfred@earthlink.net
To: F_MINOR@EMAIL.RUTGERS.EDU
Subject: GG & Perahia
Date: Wed, 2 Oct 2002 12:34:29 -0700
Then some of you started your comparisons so I got out my GG recording >of
the Bach Concerto for piano and orchestra No. 5. and played the GG >and
Perahia one right after the other. What a difference there is in >the
piano. Perahia just doesn't show the same enthusiasm for the >piano in
this recording that GG does in his. GG sounds more "up >front". Perahia
almost sounds like he is in the background. It seems >to me that Perahia is
putting more enthusiasm into his conducting. >Like I said, it is very
enjoyable.
Good grief! You call Gould's style "enthusiastic"? IMHO it sounds more like
an attack on the music!
You are certainly entitled to your opinion but personally, I can't stand the
Gould recordings of the keyboard concertos. Whenever I try to listen to them
I am turned off at once by the harsh, aggressive, and above all percussive
nature of his playing. It sounds like he's trying to hammer out the notes
rather than connect to the music. "Up front" is the understatement of the
year! And I wouldn't consider it a compliment...
Gould's recording of the keyboard concertos is sort of a distillation of
everything I dislike about Gould's Bach, all put into one recording. With
other pieces, like the Goldbergs/Partitas/Toccatas, I am able to get past
the things I hate in order to appreciate the things I love about Gould's
Bach (of which there are many, don't get me wrong.) But in my opinion the
keyboard concertos are Gould at his worst. The music sounds incredibly
harsh, and the piano sounds like it's trying to dominate the orchestra by
sheer force of will. Gould plays practically EVERYTHING with that annoying
percussive staccato, and it sounds like he's trying to make a piano sound
like a harpsichord for reasons that I cannot understand (the harpsichord was
never a big success as a solo instrument in a concerto, for a very good
reason!)
In contrast, when Perahia plays, he's working WITH the orchestra, not
against them. The melodic lines sound like he's singing them. And as for
"enthusiasm," how about the first movement of the A major concerto?
Cristalle
_________________________________________________________________
Send and receive Hotmail on your mobile device: http://mobile.msn.com